Is Pu’er Cha Bing an Investment Tool?

Zhongcha brand old pu'er chabing

Zhongcha ( short for Zhongguo Chaye Gongsi, ie China Tea Trade Company ) had been basically the only tea factory in Yunnan a few years after the Communist takeover, until after the mid 1980’s when the tight control of the market is gradually relaxed. Therefore merchandize from that period abound. In the earlier days, theer was no production date on the label, people now just claim how old a product is. This one claims to be 50 years old, and fetching over a hundred thousand CNY. It comes complete with new crocoach bites and older moisture stains. I’d rather donate the money to a nursery home.

I have not seen Harry for over three years now, so it is okay to read my notes on the iPad waiting for him in the uncomfortable tiny chair of this pricy little cafe at the entrance to the basement theatre in this giant skyscraper that is one of the world’s most expensive property — the International Finance Centre in Hong Kong. The coffee is mediocre and the space is crammed. It is understandable; they must have a big rent to pay.

Pu’er Cha Bing: Investment or Just a Toy?

Harry is the head of an investment advisory of an international financial company. His office is high, high above this cafe. It was a delight to catch up with him; those I maintain friendship with are all nice guys after all.

He asked me quite a bit about collecting pu’er discuses ( cha bing ). Like a lot other high income middle class males in Hong Kong, Harry aspires to collecting red wine and those compressed tea objects, thinking that they will rise in value in time and are good gastronomic products. Harry was certainly not the first friend to ask about such subject, and I believe a lot have been persuaded by the many seemingly harmless neighbourhood or hideaway teashops into stocking up at least a few.

If he were buying products that are a few hundred dollars a piece I would not be triggered to write about it, but he was talking about many tens of thousand USD a piece.

Confronting the Facts

If you have read my other writings about compressed pu’er products, you may remember that I do not have similar opinion as many others in the trade. I do not think that they are any higher gastronomic value than comparable loose leaf. What about investment value? Don’t they all appreciate in time?

Before you read on, please be warned that this article may offend tea consumers like Harry himself; or some tea merchant friends who rely on the speculation of pu’er cha bing to pay the rent or the accounting fees for their Panama account. All are welcome to comment below.

A pu'er chabing from the 1940's

A pu’er cha bing that claims to be from Tong Chang Hao, a real old tea factory in Yunnan before the Communist regime. What would you do with such a thing even if it is genuine?

Don’t all pu’er appreciate anyway?

They really do, overall speaking, but there are big details that you should know, if by any chance you are interested in buying some for your “investment”.

Before we go into these details, let’s revisit a few basic facts:

  1. There are two distinct sub-categories of compressed pu’ers: shengcha and shu cha. Shengcha is said to continue to improve in taste value, while some believe shu cha reaches peak in less than 10 years. Because of that myth, shengcha is always fetching a higher price than shu cha even at the same chronological age. Shengcha is the type that takes up the majority of speculative trading.
  2. It makes perfect sense to stock up a few pieces of cha bings for maturity and to save some money not having to buy from more expensive matured stocks, since pu’er does improve with time under the right conditions and matured ones always demand a higher price, as in wine. However, it is quite another matter to buy with the intention to invest. This article deals with this latter idea.
  3. This article is not about normal trade to trade auction, which happens in many commodities, including matured cha bings. However, this is not to say there are no issues even in such auctions. Fakes, forgeries and other malpractices abound, but these are other topics.
  4. Some cha bings may go for a few tens while some others could be hundreds of thousands USD. The stake can be much higher to certain people and the temptation to cheat equally high.
fu yuan chang cha bing

This is one of the thousands of products made to look like antique with a torn label of a shop name from the first half of the last century.

If you do not mind overpaying a few cups of tea, it is okay you buy by following your impulse. If you want real value for your money or look at it as investment, you have to know in the very beginning that whether you are already over paying for a decorative disc made of dried tealeaves. That brings us to point number 1:

No valuation standard in compressed pu’er

You may have seen a few pamphlets or magazines printed in simplified Chinese declaring the values of so and so grade of so and so year from so and so factory is worth this and that dollar ( or Chinese yuan ). The fact is, within Mainland China, where there is no freedom of press and no freedom of association, would there be any independent price report? Do you ever think that even any economic figures the Beijing government announced have been real? What do you think that helped fuel the pu’er price bubble in the beginning anyway? Unlike wine, there is no independent critic or valuation system for the commodity at all. As far as I know, there is not even a task force set out to do that or any institution intended for such development. The interest of too many parties are involved. Many are too dangerous to touch. The price tag on any particular high price cha bing is open for interpretation.

7 Responses

  1. Leo Kwan says:

    @Ming, maybe you should not drink that Laos shengcha pu’er if it is stored badly. Bad storage attracts the wrong group of fungi. Likely dust and germs as well. Your health is far more precious than any dried leaves.

  2. chiguchi says:

    An investment in commodities need to have the following to considered. the initial value (by market price of trading at release). The intergrity of the warehousing. climate control as to humidity, temp and the effects of aging. and finally the final value at sales established by auction, qualified appraisers and the actual sale. The wine industry can be used as a guideline or the art world. The Pu’er tea market sound like no standards available yet for an investor to consider. Perhaps the reason to invest is his own belief that he has something exceptional and the ability to tell others of his great tea he has. I been told that the value of art is what the buyer wants to pay. Perhaps Pu’eris similar. Let the buyer be happy that he believes he has the best tea because he paid a ton of money. food for thought.

    • Leo Kwan says:

      That is exactly what I mean, and yet those who have been paying ridiculous amount of money for much lower value are professional investors or people who think they are finance savvy. I think their knowledge in tea needs to match up with their common sense in the money market, or they simply have an emotional hole there they need something else to fill.

    • Sam says:

      I would classify pu erh as an ‘alternative investment asset’. In the financial world such assets are known to be less transparent, harder to value, and have less liquidity in transactions. Yet in such a situation, an investor with knowledge can outperform investors with less knowledge.

  3. Ming says:

    Amazing, and so eye opening. I myself have connections in China, and before I though that the best is always ridiculously expensive, but it was all an illusion. But may I ask for a certain unit of puer tea, of which I have the intention to invest in, what is a good price range for something with the gastronomical effects? Which way do you suggest, how do you do it, if I may what is the “Leo way”. Price is but a number, but it is the skill to see through market flaws that will help me become a skilled collector

    • Leo Kwan says:

      @Ming, You are always welcome to send any info, sample, or photos of whatever you want to get to know better of. However, I have to be honest that there are literally hundreds of pu’er producers in Yunnan alone, if not thousands ( counting those that are outside of the book ), we cannot say we know even a fraction of them. We rely also on tasting, research and interviews to understand what is the physicality and backgrounds of any tea. We are always learning, and look forward to your input.

      • Ming says:

        Thank you! This year I’m trying to invest in both puer and zisha teapots….there are so many options in and out of China. A was given a Lao sheng pu tea brick last year and my friend said he had stored it for decades in Canada. But the storage seemed not as “organized” as yours and the leaf appearance was light brown and the liquor came out a little muddy, maybe I brewed it incorrectly. I’d hate to waste it,

Leave a Reply